Do-Overs

Ken AshfordHistoryLeave a Comment

What if we could go back in time and vote again on past presidential elections?  Who would we vote for, using 20/20 hindsight?

Scripps Howard News Service polled Americans to find out.  What winner would have lost?  Well, Nixon, of course, would have lost his re-election bid in 1972.  And Bush 42 would have lost — twice.

1964

Lyndon B. Johnson (D)

50%

Barry Goldwater (R)

23%

1968

Richard Nixon (R)

34%

Hubert H. Humphrey (D)

31%

George Wallace (I)

15%

1972

George McGovern (D)

42%

Richard Nixon (R)

39%

1976

Jimmy Carter (D)

52%

Gerald Ford (R)

35%

1980

Ronald Reagan (R)

56%

Jimmy Carter (D)

30%

John Anderson (I)

6%

1984

Ronald Reagan (R)

64%

Walter Mondale (D)

24%

1988

George H. Bush (R)

53%

Michael Dukakis (D)

33%

1992

Bill Clinton (D)

52%

George H. Bush (R)

30%

Ross Perot (I)

12%

1996

Bill Clinton (D)

56%

Bob Dole (R)

25%

Ross Perot (Ref.)

12%

2000

Al Gore (D)

46%

George W. Bush (R)

38%

Ralph Nader (G) or
Pat Buchanan (Ref.)

9%

2004

John Kerry (D)

46%

George W. Bush (R)

40%

Ralph Nader (I)

7%